Schools could be targeted under ‘conversion practices’ Bill for safeguarding kids, lawyers warn

A leading UK law firm has warned that the Government’s ‘conversion practices’ Bill could criminalise teachers for making safeguarding decisions about gender-confused pupils.

In an article, Irwin Mitchell highlighted that that Keeping Children Safe in Education (KCSIE) guidance requires schools to exercise care when responding to ‘social transition’ requests. But the law firm noted that just a “single conversation” resulting from the request, or following the law on single-sex spaces, could fall foul of the Bill.

Under the Draft Conversion Practices Bill for England and Wales, a person could face up to five years in prison for expressing “emotional pressure” that causes a person to believe they do or do not have a particular “identity” or “sexual orientation”.

‘Preferred pronouns’

Irwin Mitchell explained that the Bill creates an “open-ended concept of transgender identity”, covering “non-binary identities as well as a wide range of alternative gender identities”.

The law firm emphasised: “KCSIE recognises the religion or belief rights of pupils and staff and says that schools supporting social transition might discuss options such as using names instead of pronouns. Will refusing to use a child’s preferred pronouns amount to an abusive conversion practice? That’s not clear.

“And, what about other children who don’t want to use preferred pronouns to refer to their classmates or refuse to accept their gender identity? Are you required to compel them to do so, to avoid being accused of encouraging or assisting conversion practices?

“Again that’s not clear. Nor is it as outlandish as you might think. The age of criminal responsibility is 10 and the Bill doesn’t require there to be any duty of care between the alleged perpetrator and alleged victim.”

‘Devasting problems’

Maya Forstater, CEO of women’s rights charity Sex Matters, agreed that the proposals are “on a collision course with school safeguarding responsibilities”.

“This bill will cause devastating problems for schools who are trying to perform their central duty of keeping children safe.”

She warned: “Teachers, headteachers and school governors could be threatened with jail for following statutory safeguarding guidance.”

Also see:

Baroness Cass: ‘I cannot support Govt’s Conversion Practices Bill’

Conversion practices Bill ‘a disastrous legislative misstep’ for religious freedom

Labour MPs join rising tide of criticism against ‘conversion therapy’ Bill

Telling someone ‘you are not a cat’ could be illegal under Govt’s conversion practices Bill

Related Resources