Baroness Hilary Cass, author of a review into the care of gender-confused children, has told MPs and Peers that the Government’s draft ‘conversion practices’ law is unworkable.
Speaking to the Westminster Committee tasked with scrutinising the Bill, Lady Cass raised significant concerns about the impact of the plans on clinicians and parents.
Under the Draft Conversion Practices Bill for England and Wales, a person could face up to five years in prison for applying “emotional pressure” that causes a person to believe they do or do not have a particular “transgender identity” or “sexual orientation”.
Jeopardy
Lady Cass told the Committee that the Bill is not “anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences”. When pressed on whether she was in favour of progressing the draft proposal, she responded: “I can’t support the Bill in its current form”.
In relation to healthcare professionals, she explained: “the problem is in the definition of what it means for a person to fall far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position, and at the moment we don’t have clear standards, but moreover standards are highly contested in this area”.
To illustrate her concern, she pointed out that it would very easy for a gender-confused young person, distressed at not being set on the “medication pathway”, to report a clinician whom they believed had acted in “a very negative way”.
‘This Bill doesn’t work’
The consultant paediatrician added: “The further challenge is that, unfortunately, there are also malign actors, and I’ve seen social media quotes from them, looking to exploit young people who may feel that they have had an adverse experience to pursue some of the people working in this field.”
Furthermore, she said, the Bill exposes parents to the risk of criminal proceedings, for “things like not agreeing to changing pronouns for your child” or “restricting money if you think they’re going to use it to get a breast-binder or hormones”. Such instances, she continued, “could fall within the reach of this Bill” and raised “significant worries”.
Simon Calvert, Deputy Director of The Christian Institute, told The Daily Telegraph: “Baroness Cass is clear that the Bill doesn’t work, and the Government needs to listen to her.”
‘Fundamental concerns’
Stephanie Davies-Arai, the founder of Transgender Trend, commented: “Along with clinicians, Baroness Cass also raised concerns about the impact on parents having difficult conversations with children which may cause alarm and distress.
“As the author of a four-year independent investigation into this area Baroness Cass is best placed to understand what the unintended consequences will be of this Bill and the harm that will be caused to parents and professionals working with highly distressed and vulnerable children.”
Sex Matters Chief Executive Maya Forstater, described Lady Cass’ evidence as “arguably the most important intervention on the Bill to date” and questioned how it could “feasibly progress” given her “fundamental concerns”.
Conversion practices Bill ‘a disastrous legislative misstep’ for religious freedom
Tavistock whistleblower explains how ‘conversion practices’ law will endanger kids
Labour MPs join rising tide of criticism against ‘conversion therapy’ Bill
Telling someone ‘you are not a cat’ could be illegal under Govt’s conversion practices Bill
