Clinicians giving evidence not aware of conversion therapy actually happening

Health professionals have given evidence that conversion practices are not happening in the UK health system.

Speaking to the Joint Committee scrutinising the draft Conversion Practices Bill, gender specialists said they were unaware of any cases of abusive conversion therapy in psychiatry. They warned the Bill would simply put the pressure of criminal sanction on an already difficult discipline.

Under the draft Conversion Practices Bill for England and Wales, a person could face up to five years in prison for applying “emotional pressure” that causes a person to believe they do or do not have a particular “transgender identity” or “sexual orientation”.

Clinical experience

Giving evidence to the committee, Dr Igi Moon, Senior Clinician at the Gender Plus clinic who supports the Bill, admitted she had no experience of abusive conversion practices happening: “I can’t say I’ve seen exorcisms and abuse. That does not mean it isn’t happening, but that is just my personal clinical experience.”

Dr Lisa Morrison, Chief Regulation and Standards Officer at the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy stated: “We’re not aware of any complaints that have solely focused or covered conversion practices.”

Clinical Psychologist Dr Anna Hutchinson told the committee: “I’ve worked with hundreds to thousands of young people and many colleagues who have worked with young people exploring their gender and who identify as trans, and I have to be honest, I have never heard of any experience of abusive conversion practices as described by this Bill.”

‘Profoundly distressing’

Dr Hutchinson also raised concerns over the Bill’s broad and undefined terms, saying: “My concern would be that everyday practitioners on the frontline would have to be taken to court in order to work out what the definition of the abuse is, that this will be tested on day-to-day practitioners.”

She explained that not only would it be “profoundly distressing” for the psychologists taken to court as test cases, it would have a chilling effect that would leave medical professionals “very afraid to work in this area” for fear of being accused.

The clinician noted: “The term conversion therapist has been thrown around quite a lot in this field — not accurately.” She added that both Baroness Cass and former Health Secretary Wes Streeting have been labelled conversion therapists in the past.

Conservative Peer Baroness Browning warned of the impact already happening among clinicians: “I am aware of psychologists and therapists who have actually left their professional bodies because of the need of affirmation”.

Targeting clinicians

Writing for The Times, doctor and a former Health Minister Zubir Ahmed MP echoed the concerns voiced in the evidence session and highlighted the importance of protecting medical professionals.

He said: “The truth is that this draft bill is wading into a contested clinical space, where live and often bitter debates between medical professionals continue to happen even after the Cass review.”

He continued: “Some experts have even suggested that if the draft bill is not amended, it could be misused by activists as a way of targeting those clinicians who take the same cautious approach that the Cass review set out.”

The MP explained that “any government should be wary of the unintended impact of the laws they propose, and must listen to the evidence of the professionals on the front line”.

Also see:

Baroness Cass: ‘I cannot support Govt’s Conversion Practices Bill’

Conversion practices Bill ‘a disastrous legislative misstep’ for religious freedom

Labour MPs join rising tide of criticism against ‘conversion therapy’ Bill

Telling someone ‘you are not a cat’ could be illegal under Govt’s conversion practices Bill

Related Resources