Government proposals to ban ‘conversion therapy’ could have been used to silence those who succeeded in ending Tavistock’s puberty blockers scandal, a whistleblower has warned.
Dr David Bell, a former staff governor at the Tavistock and Portman Trust, was subjected to disciplinary proceedings after he reported clinicians’ concerns about patient welfare at England’s Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) in an internal report.
Now, in an interview with The Daily Telegraph, the retired consultant psychiatrist has raised concern that the Draft Conversion Practices Bill would have supported GIDS’ rush to affirm children in the opposite sex and acted as a “serious threat to those who raised the alarm”.
‘Lost the debate’
Dr Bell said: “if this bill were law, it would have made it more difficult for people who wanted to bring issues around the care that young people were being treated [with] to public attention. And so more generations of children and adolescents would suffer the damage of the wrong treatment.”
It will create an atmosphere of fear, which is what it is intended to do.
He noted that since the “trans lobbies have lost the debate” over Tavistock’s approach, the legislation is “a way of trying to recolonise the territory in a threatening manner that will have very serious consequences for children, parents, teachers, and other government and non-government organisations and institutions.
“It will create an atmosphere of fear, which is what it is intended to do.”
The psychiatrist emphasised: “This law is a way of making it appear as if the right attitude is to affirm children and that’s the very thing that I, and many other people, said was damaging children and which was confirmed by the Cass review.”
‘Fear’
Dr Bell stated: “The evidence for conversion practices, and this has been acknowledged, is extremely poor. There is also no evidence for conversion practices being carried out by qualified professional doctors, health care practitioners or psychologists.”
He highlighted that the Bill fails to define key terms such as “gender identity” and “conversion”, when the “the extreme things that it does mention are already covered by criminal law”.
The likely result of which, he warned, will be that clinicians stop seeing gender-confused children “for fear of criminal proceedings. This already happened in other countries.”
Under the Draft Conversion Practices Bill for England and Wales, a person could face up to five years in prison for expressing “emotional pressure” that causes a person to believe they do or do not have a particular “identity” or “sexual orientation”.
Stonewall
According to The Telegraph, Stonewall has been granted extraordinary access to Government in relation to the proposed legislation.
In June, when the Bill was published, the controversial pro-trans charity celebrated its “central role” in pushing for a ban and pledged to continue to work hard to ensure that it is “robust”, “effective” and without “loopholes”.
Sex Matters Chief Executive Maya Forstater commented: “The draft Conversion Practices Bill is a trans activist’s dream.”
“Stonewall’s access to No 10 and Government departments specifically to discuss conversion practices speaks volumes about whose viewpoints are reflected, and whose concerns are going unheard.”

Labour MPs join rising tide of criticism against ‘conversion therapy’ Bill
Telling someone ‘you are not a cat’ could be illegal under Govt’s conversion practices Bill
NI public overwhelmingly rejects push to ban so-called conversion therapy