Banning so-called conversion therapy in England and Wales will criminalise responsible Christian parents and church pastors, the Minister for Equalities has been warned.
Signatories to a letter prepared by the Greater Love Writing Group, urged Bridgette Phillipson MP to abandon her Conversion Practices’ Draft Bill. They also offered to meet with Government officials to explain “the historic, universal Christian understanding of marriage, human nature and sexual ethics”.
More than 1600 church leaders and 2000 supporters from a wide range of Christian denominations told Phillipson that they will not cease to teach God’s ways faithfully, “even if an unjust law should make us criminals for doing so”.
Glorious truths
The letter affirmed the goodness of marriage — defined as “the sexually-faithful union of one man and one woman for life” — the “moral duty to keep sexual intimacy for marriage”, and that “sex cannot be changed”.
Yet, it warned, under the draft Bill, clergy, ministers, pastoral workers and Christian parents teaching these truths would inevitably be viewed by some as making “attempts to ‘change’” someone’s “‘orientation’ or ‘identity’”.
Through the letter, Greater Love set out the Christian understanding of conversion as a “turning, in obedience to Jesus Christ and by the power of the Holy Spirit, from self, sin and pride to humble trust in God”.
But by “appropriating this Christian language as a label for an ill-defined and wide-ranging criminal offence”, it said the Government had not only drafted legislation that is “grossly offensive to Christians”, but also criminalised a core aspect of Christian doctrine and practice.
Religious police
Dr Julie Maxwell, Deputy Director of Lovewise, member of the Church of England’s General Synod, and one of the letter’s authors said: “I signed this letter as someone who is involved in the pastoral support of young people and also of parents.
“I signed because of the danger the proposed bill poses to those who seek to teach and guide children and young adults in historic Christian biblical teaching on marriage, relationships, sexual intimacy and gender.
“The proposed bill claims to protect children but in fact turns the law on those who have primary responsibility for protecting children – those who care for and guide children as they navigate their development through puberty and adolescence.”
Co-author Graham Nicholls, Director of Affinity, said the Bill would “suppress freedom of speech and freedom of religion” and would mark “the beginning of policing any moral conversation”. He added: “Hundreds of thousands of Christians will likely fall foul of this law.”
‘Trojan horse’
Writing in The Daily Telegraph, Revd Dr Matthew Roberts, also part of the Greater Love Writing Group, described the Bill as “a Trojan horse”. He continued: “It presents itself as dealing with a terrible and prevalent abuse of innocent victims.
“But what it actually does is criminalise disagreement with the peculiar ideology of the LGBTQ+ movement: that we have an ‘identity’ which arises from our feelings, and fulfilling that ‘identity’ through sexual activity or medical/surgical bodily modification is essential”.
“It is so broad that it will catch anyone who questions whether this is so, or whether a particular “identity” is real. Given that there are literally hundreds of these on offer (Ceteramoric? Pomosexual? Stargender? Me neither), and that biological sex is a basic and inescapable reality, that will probably include most normal people.”
“The activists pushing for this bill are frustrated that they have failed to win the war for our culture. And so, on the pretext of a manufactured panic about kinds of abuse which are already and quite rightly illegal, they have persuaded the Government to put forward a speech-crime bill to silence anyone who disagrees with their reality-defying ideology.”
Overreach
The Church of England recently raised concerns that the Government’s plans risked criminalising consensual prayer and pastoral care.
A church statement explained that while the General Synod had supported bringing forward a ban, it is “important to ensure that any legislation does not unintentionally criminalise providing appropriate prayer and pastoral care to those who seek it”.
The Roman Catholic Church has also criticised the Bill for going “far beyond the protection of citizens, overreaching into normal daily family life, pastoral conversations and everyday teaching”, and called for it to be abandoned.

Tavistock whistleblower explains how ‘conversion practices’ law will endanger kids
Labour MPs join rising tide of criticism against ‘conversion therapy’ Bill
Telling someone ‘you are not a cat’ could be illegal under Govt’s conversion practices Bill