Parents could be treated as abusers for making ordinary decisions for their children under plans to ban ‘conversion practices’, the leader of the Ulster Unionist Party (UUP) has warned.
Writing in The News Letter, Jon Burrows emphasised that the “law must recognise that parental responsibility is entirely different from controlling an adult partner”, and children “may become upset, anxious or distressed when boundaries are imposed”.
Yet he noted that Eóin Tennyson’s Conversion Practices (Criminalisation) Bill could endanger a “responsible parent” for seeking to guide their child in issues such as “sexuality, gender identity, relationships or choices they believe could have lasting consequences”.
Police investigation
The UUP leader, who spent 22 years in policing, stated: “Parents should not need a King’s Counsel sitting at the kitchen table before having difficult conversations with their children.
“Nor should pastors, counsellors or other responsible adults have to fear that sensitive, sincerely expressed guidance might trigger allegations requiring police investigation.”
Although he agreed that people must be protected from abuse, he said that “a noble objective is no excuse for dangerous legislation” and attempting to justify it by listing crimes that are already illegal is “deeply misleading”.
Exposing lies
He explained: “Rape is already among the most serious criminal offences, carrying a potential sentence of life imprisonment. Serious assaults involving electric shocks could constitute grievous bodily harm or other serious offences, depending on the circumstances. Unlawful detention, threats and harassment are likewise already addressed through criminal legislation.
“These are not behaviours awaiting the invention of a new criminal offence.
“Indeed, the maximum sentence under this bill is just two years’ imprisonment. Would anyone seriously suggest that corrective rape should be prosecuted under legislation carrying a two-year maximum rather than the existing law of rape, with its potential life sentence? Of course not.”
Vote
In September, MLAs ignored warnings raised by their colleagues by voting 46 to 29 in favour of Tennyson’s Bill.
Minister of Education Paul Givan had highlighted that the Bill’s supporters are seeking to criminalise “free speech” that they find “offensive”, whether spoken by family members, pastors or members of the public.
He argued that “nobody has the right not to be offended in a free and democratic society. I am offended daily by what people often have to say, it causes me distress, but I don’t believe for one moment that I should have the right to take them to court.”
Under the proposals, parents and church leaders could face up to two years in prison if they are deemed to be intending “to change or suppress sexual orientation or gender identity”. This, for example, could include refusing a child’s request for puberty blockers.
NI public overwhelmingly rejects push to ban so-called conversion therapy
NI Assembly urged to clarify rules after MLAs blocked from probing ‘gender identity’
Stormont exposes flaws of ‘hazardous’ conversion therapy Bill
Stormont ‘conversion therapy’ Bill enables self-ID in law, top KC warns
