Transsexual in legal battle for birth sex to ‘be forgotten’

A man who is living as a woman is battling the Government in court in an attempt to erase records identifying him as male.

Government lawyers say there is no need to remove the transsexual’s history and its policies on the issue strike the right balance.

However, the 44-year-old claims the current system breaches human rights laws.

Secure

Known only as “C” for legal reasons, he is challenging the process used by job centres at a case in London’s High Court.

Currently the Department for Work and Pensions processes records of transsexuals under a special, more secure, format.

This means only those with authorisation from a manager can see a claimants’ full record.

It says this balances C’s legal rights while allowing the Department to do its work.

Forgotten

C has a Gender Recognition Certificate and claims he experienced “intrusive and humiliating interactions” at job centres.

C’s lawyer commented: “She says her previous gender identity as male should be forgotten, except where it is strictly necessary.”

The Scottish Transgender Alliance is helping C’s legal team gather more evidence and has described the legal battle as a “test case”.

Relativism

Last week a newspaper columnist criticised the “spreading cult of relativism” in the wake of the Eurovision Song Contest being won by a male who wants to be described as female.

Conchita Wurst sings in a dress and was referred to as a woman by the media.

Brendan O’Neill said that just because Wurst wants to be described as “she” when performing, “does that mean we all have to comply with this rather strange demand, no questions asked?”

“Does objective reality – the fact that there are biological differences between men and women, and that the vast majority of humankind decides whether someone is a man or woman by those biological attributes – count for nothing in the face of one person’s wish to be known as something he is not?”, he posed.

Related Resources