This content requires the Adobe Flash Player. Download Adobe Flash Player here.

Committee wants to hear
views on smacking plans



The Justice Committee of the Scottish Parliament wants to receive the views of anyone with an interest in the Criminal Justice Bill.

The Bill includes plans to ban all smacking of children aged under three. There are also other proposals to further change the law on the physical punishment of children.

The Christian Institute opposes any change to the current law on physical punishment. The Institute believes the current law is firm enough and fair enough, and the new proposals are totally unworkable. Under the planned new law, ordinary parents would be plunged into fear and confusion.

It is likely that the issue of a smacking ban will go on until December 2002, when a crunch vote is expected. As the Criminal Justice Bill makes progress through the Scottish Parliament there will be other opportunities for interested parties to make their views known.

The Christian Institute has published a briefing on the Executive's smacking proposals. Locking up Parents? can be downloaded for free (right).

The deadline for submitting evidence is Monday 29 April 2002.

Tips for writing

Sending a submission

Useful documents

Tips for writing:

If you are a lawyer, a police officer or a social worker and you want to object to the proposals please contact Jon Phillips at the Christian Institute for more information.

When making your submission to the committee:

  • Be brief. One page of A4 is fine. Use your own words.
  • Use well measured and moderate language, but be firm.
  • Say if you yourself were smacked as a child under the age of three and it never did you any harm.
  • Say if you are a parent.
  • Say if you have smacked your own children under the age of three.

Sending a submission:

Interested individuals and organisations are invited to submit written evidence to the Committee. The closing date for evidence is 29 April.

Evidence at this stage should preferably be typewritten, short and concise (up to 4 sides of A4). Evidence can be submitted in electronic form by e-mail (preferably in MS Word 97). Postal submissions will also be accepted.

Your name will be published along with your submission, but not your address. If you would like your name also to be kept private, but are happy for the text of the submission to be published, simply state this in your submission. If you would prefer that nothing of your submission be published, simply state this in your submission. The Justice Committee will comply with your request.

Evidence should be submitted to:

justice.committee@scottish.parliament.uk

Or:
The Justice Committee
The Scottish Parliament
Edinburgh
EH99 1SP



  New Briefing:

New Briefing, Locking up Parents

pdf
Word
html



Justice Minister, Jim Wallace
Justice Minister, Jim Wallace, has introduced a Bill to ban all smacking of under threes

Useful documents:

Justice Committees' call for responses

Relevant section of the Criminal Justice Bill
(Full version)

Relevant section of the Bill's Explanatory Notes
(Full version)

Relevant section of the Bill's Policy Memorandum
(Full version)

Research into the effects of smacking

Responses to the Executive's initial consultation on the physical punishment of children